“Indian Hate” in America — When Did it Begin & Why?
I was inspired to write this blog by an excellent think piece titled “Why the U.S. Anger Against Indian Immigrants” by high school classmate Shyam Venkatesan in the January 15, 2026 Hindu Business Line (see weblink and PDF attached below).
In my opinion — and before the situation deteriorates further — the U.S. based “desi” community needs to take a long hard look at itself and ask why so much hate, why now, and what steps must be taken to protect itself while also building bridges with mainstream America.
Hanuman Statue
This new animus becomes a potent mix when viewed in the context of online antipathy towards the achievements and prosperity of Indian Americans. It has been gathering steam for some time while a recent controversy added fuel to the fire: the erection of a 90-foot tall Hanuman statue (part of a Hindu temple) in Sugarland, Texas (see pic below). The statue caused anger among far-right Christian nationalists who called it a “demon,” a “false god” and raised doubts about how the project overcame zoning regulations.
Texas Republican Alexander Duncan who opposed the statue used “outrage against idolatry” as a jumping off point and justification for a Senate campaign that failed to advance. Although Duncan’s strategy was a bust, the rising anti-Indian/anti-Hindu backlash was felt nationwide and echoed simultaneously by the fraught H-1B visa debate for highly skilled immigrant workers that sparked even more anti-Indian rhetoric.
Although freedom of religion is embedded in the U.S. Constitution and guaranteed by the First Amendment, the question remains: why erect an eye-popping mega statue when the hate quotient is through the roof?Guarded round-the-clock and denigrated as a “foreign deity in the heart of White Christian Texas” — the Hanuman statue is likely to remain a flashpoint and target for vandals!
Convenient Bogey!
The success and prominence of the Indian diaspora in high-income white-collar jobs — over the past three decades and more — has fueled resentment and envy. Indians are everywhere: not only at 711 convenience stores, gas stations, and taxi driving jobs of the 1980s-1990s, but also in the highest levels of government, academia, finance and banking, engineering and research, medicine, media, entertainment, heading up Fortune 500 companies and small businesses and, of course, high-tech! The fact that they achieved this through hard work (not cheating or diversity quotas) is something few believe possible.
Indian Americans have gone from being recognized, praised, and valued for their contributions and skills by colleagues, managers, and leadership to suddenly being vilified — a transition that did not happen overnight. Their visibility now infuriates some elements of the larger population who need a convenient bogey to blame for their own misfortunes and lack of progress.
During the 2024-2025 election cycle, Indians were accused of being “third world invaders,” “job stealers,” and “visa scammers” by Republican leaders in the MAGA (Make America Great Again) movement. And because they hold 71 percent of H-1B visas, Indian tech professionals were seen as “taking jobs” from Americans.
The Trump Administration has been directly to blame. White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller has unjustifiably accused India of “cheating on immigration policies.” While nativist rhetoric simmers and spills over within the MAGA base, the Administration has done nothing to quell it. Far right fringe figures are saying, America’s doors should be “shut to idol worshipers, only White Christians should be allowed…”
The “Model Minority” Myth!
The higher profile of Indian Americans at a time of economic anxiety and polarizing immigration debates has resulted in racial slurs, dehumanizing stereotypes, and calls for violence against professionals, students, and businesses. Although the hostility is nationwide, it is more prevalent in states with large Indian populations (New Jersey, California), where anti-Hindu bias has also been reported.
Large U.S. companies (Verizon, Walmart, FedEx) that employ Indians have faced online abuse. A fatal car crash in Florida involving a Sikh truck driver with FedEx was used by extremists to fuel anti-Indian sentiment. When it was discovered that the truck driver was undocumented, it triggered a wave of online harassment of Sikhs.
Research from the Center for the Study of Organized Hate found that online racism has increased with threats of violence rising 88 percent after the 2024 election. Indians have been harassed in public spaces, had ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) called on them, and told to “go back to your country.”
Once called a “model minority” for being the best educated and wealthiest ethnic group, that myth seems outdated and laughable in the current context where online rhetoric grows harsher and community leaders call for protection from hate groups.
Dot-busters!
Hatred of Indians (and Hindus) is not new. More than 30 years ago, between 1975 and 1993, two cities in New Jersey, Jersey City and Hoboken, witnessed multiple assaults and killings of Indians by local gangs of White youths who called themselves “dot-busters” and published what amounted to a manifesto against Patels and other Hindus in a local newspaper. The name dot-buster came from the dot on the forehead or “bindi” worn by Indian women who were seen as easy targets.
The dot-buster campaign of vandalism, violence, and murder was designed to terrorize the Indian community and drive them out. In one incident, a Parsi man was beaten to death while walking home from Hoboken; his White friend was unharmed. A medical resident was beaten into a coma with baseball bats as he left his office in Jersey City Heights. Another man was assaulted with a metal pipe in his apartment, and a New York cab driver was killed on a Jersey City street. In the wake of police reluctance to prosecute, the Indian community rallied to protect itself.
Community Galvanized
In 1993, federal prosecutors took three men, all White, to trial on hate crime charges for the 1987 attack of the medical resident who was unable to identify his attackers because of brain damage from the beating. One of the defendants was a county police officer; another was the son of a police official in line to become police chief. Despite a confession and eyewitness testimony, an all-White jury acquitted the men. It was a history-making case: the first federal civil rights suit in the U.S. brought on behalf of a South Asian.
According to my research, the federal judge in the case reprimanded local investigators from the bench comparing their failures to Nazi Germany’s sanction of pogroms against Jews. With support from National Asian American groups, Jersey City Indians marched to demand change in nonviolent protest, inspired by Martin Luther King, Jr. and Mahatma Gandhi.
That outcome galvanized community members who pushed for legislation in the state and the setting of mandatory penalties for hate crimes. Parents of victims were helped to obtain justice by pressuring unwilling officials to prosecute. New Jersey schools were educated about South Asian cultures and, importantly, Indians in leadership ran for public office. (See NYT story in pdf dated Oct. 12, 1987).
Anti-Chinese Hate Crimes
More recently, other ethnic groups have been victims of hate crimes. During Covid-19, there were numerous unprovoked and often deadly attacks against Chinese men and women (or anyone that looked Asian) who were unjustly blamed for being the source of the pandemic! The hate was rooted in stereotypes that cast Asians as scapegoats. The use of terms like "Chinese virus" and "Wuhan virus" by GOP politicians in public debates led to an increase in anti-Asian sentiment.
Verbal harassment and intimidation transitioned to violence. Women workers were shot and killed at spas in the Atlanta suburbs and, in New York subways, a young woman’s face was slashed; another was pushed into the path of an oncoming train (see NPR story).
In response to the hate crime surge, organizations like STOP AAPI Hate were formed to track incidents of hate and collect data. This resulted in national legislative action, including the Biden Administration’s signing of the Covid-19 Hate Crimes Act into law in 2021 (see weblink below).
My view is that, if police had paid more attention to online hate and the daily sight of senior Asians being shoved and assaulted on street corners nationwide (on the news), they might have been better prepared.
A Once Powerful Political Subgroup Flounders!
The Indian community emerged as a powerful political subgroup over two decades ago. In 2021, then California Senator Kamala Harris became the first person of Indian origin (as well as the first woman and African American) to be the country’s vice president. The U.S. House of Representatives currently has six Indian American members while there are 50 in state legislatures (the highest number of any Asian origin group) and 350 elected officials nationwide (source: Indian-American Impact).
The 2024 presidential cycle featured two Indian American candidates from the GOP, Nikki Haley and Vivek Ramaswamy. Ramaswamy, now the Republican candidate for governor in Ohio, recently called out bigoted comments online against Indians like himself as did former South Carolina governor Haley and others on the right. They were met with even more online vitriol!
White Replacement
The core of MAGA followers — white, non-college educated men — who stew in imagined grievance related to race, gender, and immigration — believe that their place in society is rapidly slipping and that they are being replaced by other groups. This is where the “white replacement” theory comes from — the far right’s 2017 chant in Charlottesville, Virginia “Jews will not replace us” — during the first Trump Administration — has now morphed into opposition to other ethnic groups, including Indian Americans, with new battle lines drawn and fueled by the president’s mass deportation (see linked article on Great Replacement Conspiracy Theory).
Anti-immigrant rhetoric is not new. The Trump Administration often denigrates entire countries which opens the door to unprecedented xenophobia. In 2024, during the presidential election cycle, Vice President J.D. Vance’s wife, Usha, an Indian American and practicing Hindu, became a target as did the newly elected mayor of New York City, Zohran Mamdani, who faced significant online abuse targeting his identity as an Indian origin Muslim born in Uganda.
During a speech at conservative thinktank, Claremont Institute, Vance — who never fails to pander to the ultra right despite his wife being a target — said that “people whose ancestors fought in the Civil War have a hell of a lot more claim over America…” than others. This comment was met by derision from most. (See below article by Ajay Bhutoria, Biden Administration adviser).
Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) has seen anti-Indian sentiment dramatically rise during her nine years in office. As legal immigrants and naturalized citizens, Microsoft employees in her state have expressed their fears to her of becoming vulnerable whereas, in the past, their status and position kept them safe from online hate.
Lending a Helping Hand
When surrounded by unemployed or under-employed Americans drowning in credit card debt and in danger of becoming homeless, it behooves Indian Americans to step up: show empathy, donate to charities, volunteer at food banks and hospitals, and participate in neighborhood events (senior home visits, cleanups, local initiatives). Make an effort to be more active through volunteerism; call it a way to assimilate by drawing the right type of attention!
The Sikh community provided a wonderful example during Covid-19 which gained appreciation and goodwill. They distributed free cooked food and groceries up and down the East Coast as well as in other parts of the country. According to news articles, people drove 20 miles and more to pick up boxed food. In cities like New York, food packages were delivered to Americans unable to leave home (see NBC story attached).
Blending In!
When traveling in Kenya and Tanzania on work in the early 2000s, I was offended by the sight of Gujarati women seated in five star hotel lounges laden with excessive amounts of gold jewelry! The sight of them flaunting their wealth a few hundred yards away from armed guards, slums, and dire poverty (not that different from Mumbai) was an obvious red flag!
It was also tasteless and questionable behavior when viewed against the background of the 1972 expulsion of the Asian (mainly Indian) community from Uganda by former dictator Idi Amin.
I describe this incident as the kind of thing to avoid. Other behaviors to shun: being loud, showy, and obnoxious! Blending in rather than standing out and keeping a low profile could turn out to be the only way to remain safe and not become a victim — a sad reality of the world we live in! Wear your sari or ghagra-choli or kurta-pajama or sherwani to the temple or mosque or wedding reception or graduation party — but perhaps not to the park or walking down the street or when riding the subway or city bus!
Bigotry and violence are not new. What is new is deploying tropes over social media to rekindle old hatred. But social media only reflects what society puts into it. The far right is punching above its weight in impacting public discourse. Responsibility lies with sections of the political establishment and media for creating the kind of atmosphere in which racists feel empowered. This needs to stop!
Wake-up Call!
The days of being cocky and overconfident are over. The wealth and status of Indian Americans will not protect them if elements in the MAGA crowd continue to fan anti-India hate! Best to take sensible precautions: organize neighborhood watches, take self defense classes, contribute to police associations, make common cause with other ethnic groups and minorities who have suffered hate crimes — and call out bigotry and unjust comments, whether from the White House or conservative media.
The dot-buster kind of crimes might be unthinkable in the present day when there are several ethnic Indians in public office, and police bias is less of an issue — but that theory does not need testing! In the past, Indian Americans were often exempt from the petty racism directed at other people of color because their privilege and connections made them immune.That is no longer the case. Wake up!
The latest issue of New India Abroad.com celebrates recently elected Mamta Singh taking her oath of office on the Bhagavad Gita at a public inauguration on January 15 as Jersey City’s first Indian American Councilwoman-at-Large with the rather gushing comment, “the story unfolding within the Indian-American diaspora is not one of sudden arrival, but of steady ascent — from representation to responsibility, and from participation to leadership.” Also attending were New Jersey State Senator Raj Mukherji and Assemblyman Ravi Bhalla.
Three decades after the dot-busters, it was a significant step forward for Indian American representation in Jersey City’s civic leadership. But the newspaper’s commentary sounds absurdly out of place at this point in Indian American history. Let’s hope that current desi misfortunes are only a blip in the larger tapestry that is still to be written.
Ludi Joseph
Washington, D.C.
January 18, 2026
 |
| Hanuman Statue in Sugarland,Texas |
Yes, the Hanuman statue was an unpardonable and asinine overreach. A classic instance of ' Come, bull, hit me (Aa bael, mujhe mar). They could have made thousands of small Hanumans and distributed them to the Bhakts for each of them to hug or pray to or whatever. The issue that could become progressively more dangerous has not only been beautifully anlaysed by Ludi, but she also takes care to provide the most sensible solutions. Yes, the only way for our people is ,'to blend in rather than stand out' and 'to show more empathy, donate to charities, volunteer at food banks and hospitals' and so on. The American Indian needs to ensure that he/she totally desists from aping the Hindutva model of the country of his/her origin.
ReplyDeleteM V Kannan
Dear Kannan,
DeleteThank you very much for those remarks. Yes, “assimilation” has always been key but I guess some of the older generation tend to forget! Love the bull/bael analogy!
Ludi.
Excellent write-up & analysis ludi. I agree completely one should try to blend in and assimilate.. but unfortunately i see the same trend here in norway- the need to express ones contrasting differences seems to be surfacing esp in the public sphere.. Which sparks off more of our differences than common features . This might effect our future scenario here
ReplyDeleteI have forwarded yr article to others in the block n faps. Tnx fr sharing .
Dear Twinkle,
DeleteThank you for that incisive comment! Let’s hope our desh-bhakts (both in Norway and the U.S.) realize that (at this point in our shared history) it’s about survival, not showing off — and begin to modify their behavior! Hey to all the “Block” pals!
Hi Ludi, Thank you for having the bravado to address this issue and the presence of mind to see it. Truth be told, and in the current era one would be forgiven to miss it entirely, it is really not an American characteristic to show wealth. As a practical matter it just makes people a victim - target. Whether John Kerry or Pete DuPont, both wildly wealthy, they drove modest vehicles and didn’t display jewelry in public.
ReplyDeleteThe idea of democracy is that everyone is equal, so why bother?
It is sad that people tend to see Hinduism, Islam and the Jewish religion as a threat. However, on the day dedicated to the pacifism and peace of the Reverend Martin Luther King, it is clear that many people who built this country have been stepped on, too.
Your advice to get involved is the key.
Thank you!
DeleteDear Susan,
Thank you for those insights! Glad you mentioned MLK. On this auspicious day, the Indian community must acknowledge their debt to him: hope of equal protection under the law and a concrete tool to get it. It was the Civil Rights movement that laid the political groundwork for the 1965 immigration law that in turn removed restrictions against Asians entering the U.S. The Black struggle for justice also led to the 1968 passage of the first federal hate crimes legislation. Those two laws created the mechanism for federal prosecutors (in the Dot-buster case) to step in when local law enforcement dismissed bias as a motive and failed to pursue leads. The federal judge reprimanded local investigators comparing their failures to Nazi Germany’s sanction of pogroms against Jews. With support from national Asian American groups, Jersey City Indians marched to demand change and engaged in nonviolent protest — inspired by MLK who in turn was inspired by Gandhi! I found an Oct. 12, 1987 NYT story “In Jersey City, Indians Protest Violence” - attaching PDF to main blog.
Given the enormous amount of anti-immigrant sentiment being generated by MAGA influencers at the behest of the White House, this piece comes not a moment too soon. Thank you for pushing back against hate, against not only the Indian-American community, but all groups under attack. We are living in dangerous times.
ReplyDeleteThank you Lore. Appreciate your comments. Yes, these are precarious times. The White House has done nothing to stop proliferation of nativist and anti-immigrant rhetoric. Wonder where it will end!
ReplyDeleteHi Ludi,
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your very insightful article. It definitely seems like the inmates are running the asylum! It saddens me that the bullies feel like they have Carte Blanche to run roughshod over the Constitution, especially as they appear to be in the minority statistically.
Thank you Trish! Well said!
DeleteVery well, written Ludi. Regarding the Hanuman statue, what a waste of money! You may be aware of the Sardar Patel statue installed in Gujarat in 2018 which cost several hundred crores of rupees; the annual maintenance also runs into crores! The maintenance is supposedly offset by visitors’ tickets, but why can’t this money be spent on education or health care or roads or to reduce pollution? Living conditions in almost all Indian cities are abysmal, traffic is uncontrollable, and governance is nonexistent! The money wasted on statues and temples — both in India and Texas — should be put to better use!
ReplyDeleteThank you Girish! Well said! Both the state government of Gujarat and the Indian Government pushed to build the Patel statue — a pet project of the PM — and for what purpose: their own glorification! Statues say more about the persons erecting them than the ones depicted! You are right! Such a huge waste of money that could have been directed to a worthier cause!
DeleteHi Ludi — that’s an excellent article! I want you to be harsher, if you can! Few Indians are good at cross cultural activities. This is very true in India as well where identity is related to language and local culture. Rich Indian Americans should be more open to charity and social work to help the poor. They need to make an effort to be more visible and active in the local community and show they care through volunteerism!
ReplyDeleteThanks Fred for your comments. Hope the community pays attention to the risks involved! They’ve broken down social barriers in the past and can do it again!
DeleteFinally - a chance to re-read your blog. As always - well written! I like that at the outset you state, “the desi community needs to take a long, hard look at itself”. This resonated with me. We need to not just look at the outside , but look inwards and question what we, as individuals, may be doing that offends others and see if we can do anything about it. Thanks for the thought-provoking blog!
ReplyDeleteLyn — Thanks for those comments. My blog is directed at desis who go out of their way to display/show off their wealth and “superiority” to other ethnic groups! I want them to tamp down on over-the-top Diwali, Dussehra, Durga Puja and other “loud” festivals that the U.S. gen pop looks at askance! Survival is key — try not to become a juicy target for some White Supremacist, Nazi/Aryan-loving, Indian-hater-baiter! I’m sure the half-literate meth-brained bigots in Sugarland TX or Edison NJ are biding their time waiting to strike!
DeleteThe verdict in the recent palak paneer microwave oven case (BBC story) is the exact thing that should NOT be happening!
Will Indians ever change? I predict they will become wilder and more boisterous and put a target on their backs!
DeleteThe “palak paneer” couple were really taking advantage of the system! I bet the same people would have no qualms in prosecuting people for eating "meat" in India, especially minorities! FYI, to the discomfiture/shame of the RSS/BJP, the majority of Indians (acc. to a poll I saw) are now proudly meat-eating, even Brahmins! And, no more camouflaging their meat like they used to their booze in coke! (Excessive red meat eating is perhaps not a healthy trend knowing desi cardiac issues plus bad for the environment, but that’s a debate for another day)!
DeleteWell written Ludi.
DeleteThe India pohobia is in the cycle of hate that is well documented in American history and this too shall pass. While we are in the midst of this cycle I would advocate a middle ground. Obviously the community should avoid attracting attention for the wrong reasons like ostentatious display of wealth, showy and conspicuous behavior etc. At the same time they need not lose their cultural identity like the immigrant Germans did,driven by fear, when they were enmeshed in the cycle of hate during the World Wars. Participating through volunteering in their neighborhood and giving to charity would be excellent vehicles for assimilation.
/Shyam
Thank you Shyam for your comments. You are right about advocating a middle ground. That’s always a common sense approach.
Delete